Topic: [APPROVED] Tag alias: lunch_box -> lunchbox

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The tag alias #57584 lunch_box -> lunchbox has been approved.

Reason: Same thing.

lunch_box : 9 posts
lunchbox : 33 posts

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunchbox
says "A lunch box[1][2][3] (alt. spelling lunchbox)"

Google isn't much help with which is more common spelling, because various business have "lunch box" or "lunchbox" in name.

Suggest aliasing to Lunchbox because Wikipedia article title.

EDIT: The tag alias lunch_box -> lunchbox (forum #334879) has been approved by @bitWolfy.

Updated by auto moderator

(putting as reply to avoid cluttering the alias suggestion and voting)

Going through lunch_box posts:
1) post #2956452 maybe includes a bag (paper bag?) instead of a lunch box. Was drawn with finger so hard to be sure. (e621 has tags paperbag and paper_bag)

2) post #1012404 maybe has a lunch bag instead of a lunch box. (but Wikipedia's Lunchbox article includes image of "Insulated thermal bag", so maybe lunch_box tag ok there)(some "lunch bag" products at Amazon also have "lunch box" in product title)

***

Going through lunchbox posts:
1) part of me thinks post #2814170 shows plastic food containers (such as tupperware) instead of lunchboxes (but Wikipedia Lunchbox article starts with "A lunch box (alt. spelling lunchbox) refers to a hand-held container used to transport food," and since 2814170 shows characters with hand-held containers containing food ... i guess they qualify as lunchboxes.

2) post #1004256 character on right could be carrying a lunchbox, but since beach is mentioned was thinking it was maybe a cooler ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cooler )
cooler wiki says "An insulated, generally portable container often used for keeping food or beverages cold while outside ...".

3) post #151840 solo image of Balrog from Cave Story. https://cavestory.fandom.com/wiki/Balrog says "Balrog is rectangular-shaped " and "Though stated by Pixel that Balrog is intended to resemble a bar of soap, he is thought by others to be a toaster, a lunchbox, or even a flat-screen TV."

Bento box is literally just lunch box, but in Japanese, so I think an alias is correct, although if people consider the style different enough to merit its own tag, then I'm not against that either.

I think a bento box is distinguishable enough. Usually it has a removable lid with separate compartments inside, and is wider and flatter, whereas a standard lunchbox is typically a deeper box without compartments (or fewer compartments) and an attached lid. Also, perhaps the main thing is that you’re meant to eat directly out of a bento box. It functions as a dish when open. This typically isn’t the case with a normal lunchbox - you just remove the contents and eat on the table or a separate plate.

I think a bento box can imply a lunch box, as it's a particular style of lunch box.

As for "Lunch Bags", why not have a new tag for lunch bag and imply that to paper bag. The paper bag tag itself is a bit vague and can cover a character carrying a groceries paper bag or wearing one on their head.

furrin_gok said:
I think a bento box can imply a lunch box, as it's a particular style of lunch box.

As for "Lunch Bags", why not have a new tag for lunch bag and imply that to paper bag. The paper bag tag itself is a bit vague and can cover a character carrying a groceries paper bag or wearing one on their head.

+1 to both