nin10dope said:
I'll likely write a general guideline of the tag's usage and then make a TagMe.dev project

The main issue is where exactly one defines the cutoff, since can be a bit subjective what looks "statuesque" vs. what looks "natural", especially when the muscles are being flexed (which inherently increases definition).

beholding said:
The main issue is where exactly one defines the cutoff, since can be a bit subjective what looks "statuesque" vs. what looks "natural", especially when the muscles are being flexed (which inherently increases definition).

I've already taken that into account

beholding said:
The main issue is where exactly one defines the cutoff, since can be a bit subjective what looks "statuesque" vs. what looks "natural", especially when the muscles are being flexed (which inherently increases definition).

I really feel like we should have a stickied thread 'Tag Discussion' for 'hey, not quite sure which tag to use here/borderline for a tag, what does everyone else think?' instead of making a new thread every time. Neither this one nor 'Is there a tag?' thread really work for that.

kevsnowcat said:
I really feel like we should have a stickied thread 'Tag Discussion' for 'hey, not quite sure which tag to use here/borderline for a tag, what does everyone else think?' instead of making a new thread every time. Neither this one nor 'Is there a tag?' thread really work for that.

No, the Is there a tag Sticky is for that purpose as well because that ultimately is the question that defining and brainstorming tags answers.

nin10dope said:
No, the Is there a tag Sticky is for that purpose as well because that ultimately is the question that defining and brainstorming tags answers.

It's only for people who want to find a tag they don't know the name of. If the debate is, say, 'is this a leopard or jaguar?', 'is this regular rimming or deep rimming?', etc, I've been told multiple times it is not the appropriate thread and to 'create your own if you want to discuss off-topic subjects'. I would be creating 100 threads a day for all the posts I'm unsure what to tag as, so I either guess and get it wrong or I don't tag at all. I often wonder how often my edits get reverted by the artist/commissioner who insist that the tag is wrong and it's too borderline to argue TWYS.

kevsnowcat said:
It's only for people who want to find a tag they don't know the name of. If the debate is, say, 'is this a leopard or jaguar?', 'is this regular rimming or deep rimming?', etc, I've been told multiple times it is not the appropriate thread and to 'create your own if you want to discuss off-topic subjects'. I would be creating 100 threads a day for all the posts I'm unsure what to tag as, so I either guess and get it wrong or I don't tag at all. I often wonder how often my edits get reverted by the artist/commissioner who insist that the tag is wrong and it's too borderline to argue TWYS.

Ah, my bad, the Discord channel Tag Discussions is the right place for that
Although if you're that regularly unsure on how to tag things, you should probably spend time reading the tag wikis