Post in forum #255043 - [PSA] Don't use the custom flagging reason unless you have a good reason to do so.
29 days ago
2012 alcohol ambiguous_gender antelope antlers beverage brown_eyes champagne cybercorn_entropic english_text food glass gnu hat holidays hooves horn humor mammal new_year party_hat party_horn pun solo tape text

Rating: Safe
Score: 7
User: Clawstripe
Date: December 21, 2012

Now you tell us. :\ I don't think it's been all that clear, so I think Munkelzahn's suggestion is a good idea. If we users are having trouble getting it right, then it's likely the checklist needs a bit of clarification.