Topic: dress to undress alias BUR

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

Song

Janitor

The bulk update request #11363 is pending approval.

create alias wearing_clothes (0) -> clothed (1267011)
create alias semi_nude (0) -> partially_clothed (145560)
create alias semi-nude (0) -> partially_clothed (145560)
create alias semi-naked (0) -> partially_clothed (145560)
create alias nearly_naked (0) -> mostly_nude (136541)
create alias functionally_naked (0) -> mostly_nude (136541)
create alias ineffective_clothes (0) -> ineffective_clothing (9839)
create alias useless_clothes (2) -> ineffective_clothing (9839)
create alias no_top (0) -> topless (143516)

Reason: These have been tagged multiple times:
https://e621.net/post_versions?commit=Search&search%5Btags_added%5D=wearing_clothes
https://e621.net/post_versions?commit=Search&search%5Btags_added%5D=semi_nude
https://e621.net/post_versions?commit=Search&search%5Btags_added%5D=semi-nude
https://e621.net/post_versions?commit=Search&search%5Btags_added%5D=semi-naked
https://e621.net/post_versions?commit=Search&search%5Btags_added%5D=barely_clothed
https://e621.net/post_versions?commit=Search&search%5Btags_added%5D=nearly_naked
https://e621.net/post_versions?commit=Search&search%5Btags_added%5D=functionally_naked
https://e621.net/post_versions?commit=Search&search%5Btags_added%5D=ineffective_clothes
https://e621.net/post_versions?commit=Search&search%5Btags_added%5D=useless_clothes
https://e621.net/post_versions?commit=Search&search%5Btags_added%5D=no_top

The popular but undocumented mostly_clothed tag is not included since it has over 1.2k current uses. Although the synonymous mostly_dressed tag is already an alias for partially_clothed, I'd like to keep this BUR as frictionless as possible and create a separate alias where discussion wouldn't delay simpler aliases in the same batch.

The other aliases are variants of existing aliases or otherwise harmless and unambiguous.

shouldn't semi_nude be aliased to something else? as you can be semi nude (bottomless/topless) and not be partially_clothed since for whatever reason partially clothed just means having a piece of clothing aside, or partially removed. most of the results on its search are not fitting the partially_clothed tag

Song

Janitor

manitka said:
shouldn't semi_nude be aliased to something else? as you can be semi nude (bottomless/topless) and not be partially_clothed since for whatever reason partially clothed just means having a piece of clothing aside, or partially removed. most of the results on its search are not fitting the partially_clothed tag

They are variants of the existing partially_clothed aliases partially_naked, partially_nude, and semi_naked. If those have ambiguity, then all of the current *nude and *naked aliases would need to be removed as well. I think if there is to be a discussion about whether that category of tags should not be aliased, it would be better suited to a follow-up thread since modifying the BUR to instead remove those aliases would add some friction to the ease of approving this one. The posts currently tagged semi_nude can also be manually retagged to avoid being erroneously lumped in with partially_clothed in the meantime.

Edit: I have cleaned up all of the semi_nude tags to the right nude, clothed, partially_clothed, mostly_nude, bottomless, or topless tags. That should reduce some mistags as a result of this BUR. I still encourage creating a follow-up thread if this BUR gets approved or rejected to discuss removing or changing the target of the *nude and *naked aliases if they're a problem.

Updated