The tag alias #63222 lactation_pump -> milking_machine has been rejected.

Reason: Similar to breast_pump, it would be helpful to have the milking_machine tag discoverable if you are looking for lactation pumps.

EDIT: The tag alias lactation_pump -> milking_machine (forum #368780) has been rejected by @spe.

if the wiki is anything to go by, it seems like milking_machine is used for both breast_milking and penis_milking purposes.

Perhaps breast_pump should be unaliased, and a breast milking specific tag should be created - with this being an implication instead?

faucet said:
if the wiki is anything to go by, it seems like milking_machine is used for both breast_milking and penis_milking purposes.

Perhaps breast_pump should be unaliased, and a breast milking specific tag should be created - with this being an implication instead?

+1

Yeah, needs to take into account penis milking.

I tried making a BUR for this, but can't seem to resolve the transitive relationships. I'll go ahead and post my idea here anyway:

The idea of this BUR is to avoid the term "milking" whenever possible, as it is ambiguous.

The goal is to have the following:

• milking_machine is now a disambig. This could potentially mean a breast_pump, penis_pump, or an udder pump.

• milk_pump is any milk milker

• udder_pump is a milk milker that is used on udders

• breast_pump is a milk milker that is used on breasts

• penis_pump becomes the main tag for penis milkers

• bodily_fluid_pump is a tag for any device that pumps bodily fluids.

• milking_machine_(disambiguation) would be where everything that is currently milking_machine gets dumped to be retagged.

unalias breast_pump -> milking_machine

alias milking_machine -> milking_machine_(disambiguation)
alias lactation_pump -> milking_machine_(disambiguation)

alias penis_milking_machine -> penis_pump
alias penis_milker -> penis_pump

implicate udder_pump -> milk_pump
implicate breast_pump -> milk_pump

implicate milk_pump -> bodily_fluid_pump
implicate penis_pump -> bodily_fluid_pump

category milking_machine_(disambiguation) -> invalid

kyiiel said:
The goal is to have the following:

• milking_machine is now a disambig. This could potentially mean a breast_pump, penis_pump, or an udder pump.

• milk_pump is any milk milker

• udder_pump is a milk milker that is used on udders

• breast_pump is a milk milker that is used on breasts

• penis_pump becomes the main tag for penis milkers

• bodily_fluid_pump is a tag for any device that pumps bodily fluids.

• milking_machine_(disambiguation) would be where everything that is currently milking_machine gets dumped to be retagged.

What about pumps used on teats? Nipples on the abdomen or near the crotch without visible breasts.

seems superfluous to me, and potentially wrong. Milk isn't always considered a bodily fluid, so a milk_pump isn't necessarily dealing with a bodily fluid. The excretions from some characters may not be bodily fluids (e.g. robots that lactate or cum motor oil, or being used to siphon out eggs). penis_pump also seems inconsistent next to milk_pump, one being for the thing being pumped and the other being the fluid pumped out. cum_pump instead of penis_pump might be better in that regard, since cum doesn't have to come from a penis. Alternatively, nipple_pump instead of milk_pump, since it's not necessarily milk that comes out of a nipple. Though that makes me wonder if there's a difference between a penis/cum pump and a nipple/milk pump, aside from what it's used on. If a pump is sitting there unused, can you tell if it's for one, the other, or something else?

The tag alias lactation_pump -> milking_machine (forum #368780) has been rejected by @spe.