Topic: [REJECTED] Tag implication: musclegut -> overweight

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The tag implication #51072 musclegut -> overweight has been rejected.

Reason: People that are very strong (but not body-builders) are still classified as overweight (or even (morbidly) obese) on the BMI scale IRL.

Edit: Although, they are overweight with muscle, not fat, so they are perfectly healthy

EDIT: The tag implication musclegut -> overweight (forum #367641) has been rejected by @gattonero2001.

Updated by auto moderator

An excerpt from the musclegut wiki page, which you have linked to

Musclegut, also known as musclechub, refers to characters with chubby or fat stomachs who also have defined and sizeable musculature. In practice, it works as muscular + slightly_chubby or muscular + overweight.

As the tag encompasses both slightly_chubby and overweight, both of which are different weight categories, the implication would make all slightly_chubby characters with a musclegut also be tagged as overweight. Having both tags refer to the same character is heavily discouraged.

snpthecat said:
An excerpt from the musclegut wiki page, which you have linked to

As the tag encompasses both slightly_chubby and overweight, both of which are different weight categories, the implication would make all slightly_chubby characters with a musclegut also be tagged as overweight. Having both tags refer to the same character is heavily discouraged.

Ohh... good to know then! Thanks for telling me :3