titanmelon:forum

[Back: titanmelon:index]

[WIP]

Version: 0.348 [+/- 0.150]

forum stuff

If you see an incorrect date or there's a missing entry present on another wiki, please let me know ASAP, thanks

  • a p at the beginning of a forum sentence means it's a forum post, not an entire topic (eg. p forum #foo)
  • If I have linked to a forum post you deleted/quoted a post you hid, feel free to remove it from here as well without informing me
  • If something on these pages references you by an old username, feel free to update it without informing me
  • If you'd like to discuss anything related to the content on this page, feel free to DMail me :)

toc

forumdraft_clrstd

To add

Misc comments

▼ Click to collapse

5 downvoting in relation to other similar themed posts
- https://e926.net/comment/show/3045089

4 degree of difficulty tagging in relation to site/tag policy
- https://e926.net/forum/show/129208
-- counterpoint https://e926.net/forum/show/129209

3 on the infallibility of blacklists
- https://e926.net/comment/show/834199

2 https://e926.net/forum/show/212438

1 artist proficiency guidelines
- https://e926.net/forum/show/211869

index of forum discussions

Admins/Mods / particularly-precocious site members!:

If you want to copy the contents of this section to an official wiki article /tag group,

feel free to copy this section to another part of the site without asking me

Might be ordered by date/content

▼ Click to collapse

Aliases

see also tagdisamb

▼ Click to collapse

forum #197909 - Tag Alias: awd → african_wild_dog (Jun. 2016)

forum #189533 - Tag Alias: intimate → invalid_tag (Apr. 2016)

forum #189069 - Tag Alias: curvaceous → voluptuous (Apr. 2016)

forum #188993 - Tag Alias: breast_pillow → boob_pillow (Apr. 2016)

forum #187937 - Tag Implication: romantic_couple → romantic (Mar. 2016)

forum #183087 - Tag Alias: clothed_female_nude_male → cfnm (Feb. 2016)

forum #142219 - Tag Alias: masturbation_sleeve → cocksleeve (Nov. 2014)
cocksleeveinvalid_tag

forum #141490 - Tag Alias: adult → invalid_tag (Oct. 2014)

forum #140749 - Physical Gender Tag aliases/discussion (Oct. 2014)

forum #32542 Tag Alias: pawjob → footjob (Apr. 2012)

forum #17012 - Huge_breasts > Hyper_breasts (or vice versa) (Jun. 2011)

-

Alternate forms

see also tagpolicy

forum #200657 - Tag Implication: link_(wolf_form) → link (Jul. 2016)
forum #151949 - Tag Implication: link_(wolf_form) → link (Feb. 2015)

-

Ambiguous tags

forum #190453 - Puzzled why "envy" is a character? (Apr. 2016)

forum #188816 - Something needs to be DONE about tail_wrap (Mar. 2016)

forum #185266 - Ambiguous tags Discussion/listing (Feb. 2016)

-

Anatomy

See also bodytype ; tagpolicy ; taxonomy

forum #214748 - Clarification, Diphallism and Hemipenes (nov 2016)
forum #214081 - Is there a tag for urethral_process? (nov 2016)
https://e926.net/forum/show/210714
forum #208162 - cloaca (Sep. 2016)
forum #206274 - Should humans get anatomically correct if they have a humanoid penis? (Aug. 2016)
forum #204937 - Tag Implication: peacock_feather → tail_feathers (Aug. 2016)
forum #195694 - About all these "tail" tags (Jun. 2016)
forum #187583 - Regarding the "Multi_nipple" tag - (Mar. 2016)
forum #180728 - New animal_penis and animal_pussy tags, thoughts on deprecating anatomically_correct_* tags, and a tagging project (Jan. 2016)

-
forum #159304 - Sharks, fins, earsharks and what to TAG them with (May 2015)
forum #148140 - Tag alias: ungulate → hooves (Jan. 2015)

-
forum #131327 - De-alias suggestion: unguligrade --/→ hooves (Jun. 2014)
forum #111881 - Question about tagging eyes. (Mar. 2014)
forum #145901 - Ungulates and bovines (Dec. 2014)

forum #64185 - Tag Alias - "human_feet" (Mar. 2013)

forum #5300 - Usage: wide_hips tag (Jun. 2010)

-

Art [meta]

may be split into site/non-site later
see also social
https://e926.net/forum/show/211662
https://e926.net/forum/show/208536
https://e926.net/forum/show/166829

forum #167275 - help on how to draw porn?

-

Body size

forum #190595 - Tag Implication: musclegut → belly (Apr. 2016)

forum #189422 - Tagging Slim vs. Skinny (Apr. 2016)

-

Body type

See also anatomy

https://e926.net/forum/show/211721

animal_humanoid versus anthro
https://e926.net/forum/show/207650

forum #194231 - Types of anthroness. Let's make a working system! (May 2016)

forum #191425 - Not_Furry not used enough, Feral is over-broad and Anthro is vague (Apr. 2016)

forum #191207 - Levels of anthroness in tagging ? (Apr. 2016)

forum #189453 - Tag Implication: humanized → alternate_species (Apr. 2016)

forum #188594 - Bit of Help with Taurs Appreciated (Mar. 2016)

forum #189471 - Advanced tag discussion: Mutually-exclusive Body Styles (Apr. 2016)

forum #148136 - animal_ears, human, and humanoid (Jan. 2015)

forum #145008 - Calling all robot, android, mecha, etc. experts! (wiki project) (Dec. 2014)

forum #141131 - Cyborgs, Androids, and Robots. Oh my! (Oct. 2014)

forum #72311 - What's with anthro tag? (Jun. 2013)

-

Breasts

anatomy

forum #188993 - Tag Alias: breast_pillow → boob_pillow (Apr. 2016)

forum #187716 - Mammary tags discussion:[..] (Mar. 2016)

forum #20968 - Tagging of Breast Sizes - a new Forum (Jul. 2011)

forum #17012 - Huge_breasts > Hyper_breasts (or vice versa) (Jun. 2011)

-

Flora

forum #189603 - Vore & Venus Fly Traps or Pitcher Plants (Apr. 2016)

-

Sex/Gender

see also social; tagging_policy

https://e926.net/forum/show/211402
forum #208162 - cloaca (Sep. 2016)
https://e926.net/forum/show/207982
forum #195804 - Slur Tags (Jun. 2016)
forum #194788 - Gender difference designs and tagging genders (Meowstic) (May 2016)
forum #191308 - Gender tagging vent (Apr. 2016)
forum #186509 - Female hyenas and TWYS (Mar. 2016)

forum #131601 - Don't lynch me: idea for small exception to gender tagging based on source (Jun. 2014)
forum #128973 - tagging gender through TWYS - primary and secondary sexual traits (May 2014)

-

forum #169276 - Cloaca vs. Genital slit vs. "It's a girl now" PSA (Aug. 2015)
An open discussion on tagging gender with charrs
https://e926.net/forum/show/166220
forum #176950 - Vagina > Pussy (Nov. 2015)

forum #140749 - Physical Gender Tag aliases/discussion (Oct. 2014)

forum #1104 - New 'male' and 'female' wiki articles, existing gender articles (Sep. 2009)

-

Genitalia

forum #202365 - Genitalia colo(u)r discussion: Light/dark contrasts (Jul. 2016)
forum #198896 - Tag Suggestion: Furless/Hairless/Featherless Genitalia Tag (Jun. 2016)
forum #184077 - Tag Alias: Custom_Penis → Unusual_Penis (Feb. 2016)
forum #184027 - custom_penis tag (Feb. 2016)

-

Implications

forum #200657 - Tag Implication: link_(wolf_form) → link (Jul. 2016)
forum #151949 - Tag Implication: link_(wolf_form) → link (Feb. 2015)

forum #190595 - Tag Implication: musclegut → belly (Apr. 2016)

-

Invalidations

Approved
Pending

▼ Click to collapse

forum #200254 - Tag Implication: long_claws → claws (Jul. 2016)
forum #192207 - xenophilia
forum #189533 - Tag Alias: intimate → invalid_tag (Apr. 2016)
forum #188054 - How useful is the sharp_claws tag? (Mar. 2016)
forum #170074 - shoulder/s, knee/s
forum #168190 - consensual
forum #151864 - viacom
forum #151789 - hear
forum #151087 - things
forum #151043 - people, no_humans
forum #150538 - look/ing
forum #149044 - high
forum #146824 - eye
forum #146791 - slut, nymphomaniac
forum #146214 - little
forum #146172 - my
forum #146172 - little
forum #144264 - furr
forum #151864 - viacom
forum #142219 - Tag Alias: masturbation_sleeve → cocksleeve (Nov. 2014)
cocksleeveinvalid_tag
forum #141490 #2,3: - Tag Alias: adult → invalid_tag (Oct. 2014)
forum #97621 - mouth
forum #66851 - fan_art
forum #21433 - rule_34, rule34

-

Romance

p forum #197001

forum #189533 - Tag Alias: intimate → invalid_tag (Apr. 2016)

forum #187937 - Tag Implication: romantic_couple → romantic (Mar. 2016)

-

Shortcuts, tag

forum #197909 - Tag Alias: awd → african_wild_dog (Jun. 2016)

-

Site, policy

forum #221082 - The "excessive webcomic rips" rule (jan 2017)

forum #206009 - A question on "Minimum Quality Standards"

forum #154777 - Tag Search Limits? Why? (Mar 2015)

forum #145591 - Can anyone explain what the heck is the quality standard?

-

Social

see also gender

forum #217527 - Artists, which tools/programs do you like to use?

https://e926.net/forum/show/214989
https://e926.net/forum/show/213374
https://e926.net/forum/show/212899
https://e926.net/forum/show/211721
https://e926.net/forum/show/211619

forum #205338 - A Question of Preference for the Ladies (Aug. 2016)
forum #204138 - How do I get a positive record? (Aug. 2016)
forum #196609 - Circumcision
forum #185562 - Downvoting Comments are for Bullies and A-Holes (Mar. 2016) [Tranquil Bunny]

forum #156579 - so is it bothering anyone else that uploaders go "delete! delete! delete!" at the smallest things?

-

Species

see taxonomy

-

Standardization, terminology

forum #204705 - Tag Implication: huge_penis → big_penis (Aug. 2016)

forum #189069 - Tag Alias: curvaceous → voluptuous (Apr. 2016)

forum #188993 - Tag Alias: breast_pillow → boob_pillow (Apr. 2016)

forum #176950 - Vagina > Pussy (Nov. 2015)

forum #140749 - Physical Gender Tag aliases/discussion (Oct. 2014)

-

Tagging, disambiguations

forum #213082 - Dealias Discussion: disambiguating 'pair' (Nov 2016)

-

Tagging, methods

forum #220644 - Mass/Bulk Tagging (jan 2017)

forum #196457 - How do you tag? What's your technique? (Jun. 2016)

-

Tagging, misc [pending categories]

forum #218908 - Missing Piece of art, taken down or lost in the poor taggings? (Jan. 2017)

forum #218714 - Same species tags? (Jan. 2017)

forum #216820 - Root Tag Suggestion: Binary_gender/sex (dec 2016)
forum #184578 - Resolution guide and checklist (Feb. 2016)

forum #156628 - Tribadism, Frottage, Tail_Sex and Penetration tag issues (apr 2015)

Specifying two_handed_masturbation
https://e926.net/forum/show/207775

-

Tagging, Policy

see also altform, anatomy, gender, twys

▼ Click to collapse

forum #218714 - Same species tags? (Jan. 2017)

forum #217094 - [Discussion] Why are nuked tag aliases considered "irrelevant"? (dec 2016)
forum #216888 - Tagging Pokémon (dec 2016)
forum #214655 - Quick question regarding mass nukings.... (Nov 2016)
forum #213642 - Tag idea: furry male/ human female and human male/ furry female (nov 2016
forum #212039 - Tagging designs that resemble animals (Nov. 2016)
forum #210692 - Sex tag(s) discussion: Common implication listing (* → sex) etc. (Oct. 2016)
forum #209587 - What tags are actually TWYK? (Tag What You See vs. Tag What You Know) (Oct. 2016)
forum #209445 - Should "Incest" be Tag What You Know? (Oct. 2016)
forum #207069 - The tagging of Animal_Humanoid (Sep. 2016)
forum #206789 - What's considered 'Sex?' (Sep. 2016)
forum #206274 - Should humans get anatomically correct if they have a humanoid penis? (Aug. 2016)
forum #202805 - (Pokemon) Alolan Formes (Aug. 2016)
forum #200286 - Tagging question revisited: character count? (Jul. 2016)
forum #193528 - Unofficial PSA: invalid_tag vs. *_(disambiguation) (May. 2016)
forum #193471 - Pokemon tagged as real species? (cat, fox, etc) (may 2016)
forum #193208 - Preferred Character Tag Format (may 2016)
forum #187706 - Advanced Policy Discussions: Implicative/Conjunctive/Redundant/Mutually-exclusive tag usage (Mar. 2016)
forum #186509 - Female hyenas and TWYS (Mar. 2016)
#2: forum #183087 - Tag Alias: clothed_female_nude_male → cfnm (Feb. 2016)
#2: forum #182665 - Tag suggestion 2 of 2 (maybe 3): The big suggestion - Implied Species+gender tags (Feb. 2016)
#3: Redundant tagging - forum #181559 - white sclera addition? (Jan. 2016)

forum #131601 - Don't lynch me: idea for small exception to gender tagging based on source (Jun. 2014)
forum #128973 - tagging gender through TWYS - primary and secondary sexual traits (May 2014)
forum #124387 - Tagging question: character count? (Apr. 2014)

-

Tagging, projects

foo

-

Tagging, system

[Feature/Denied] TWYK tag category
https://e926.net/forum/show/210151

forum #205766 - Lore Tags Suggestion (Aug. 2016)

[add rest]

-

Taxonomy

see also anatomy ; bodytype

forum #218714 - Same species tags? (Jan. 2017)

forum #213647 - Tag: Kitsune (Nov. 2016)
forum #208106 - Should Cougar be Puma instead? (Sep. 2016)
forum #206040 - Hyena Species (Aug. 2016)
forum #204948 - Avian Megathread (Aug. 2016)
forum #199880 - Plant discussion: Tags & Wiki (Jul. 2016)
forum #199251 - Antelope/Gazelle/Deer tagging confusion (Jul. 2016)

forum #45268 - Species Tags! (Aug. 2012)
forum #28538 - Giraffes are not Equines. (Jan. 2012)

-

Translation etc. [better name pending]

forum #208182 - Question on Japanese artist names (sep 2016)

-

TWYS

see also gender, tagpolicy

forum #209587 - What tags are actually TWYK? (Tag What You See vs. Tag What You Know) (Oct. 2016)

forum #186509 - Female hyenas and TWYS (Mar. 2016)

forum #182407 - Twys - genders (Feb. 2016)

forum #179310 - TWYS is sometimes absurdly flawed. (Dec. 2015)

forum #181648 - "Tag only what you see"? Literal interpretation? (Jan. 2015)

forum #69548 - Let's compile a list of presently existing violations of TWYS (May 2013)

-

Uploading, misc.

forum #169987 - Saving images properly, a public service announcement. (Aug. 2015)

-

Uploading, policy

forum #221082 - The "excessive webcomic rips" rule (jan 2017)

forum #215348 - Steven Universe Gems Petition (dec 2016)
forum #206274 - Should humans get anatomically correct if they have a humanoid penis? (Aug. 2016)
forum #206009 - A question on "Minimum Quality Standards"

forum #178784 - Uploading tips, tricks, suggestions and recommendations? (Dec. 2015)

forum #154777 - Tag Search Limits? Why? (Mar 2015)

forum #145591 - Can anyone explain what the heck is the quality standard?

forum #146158- Humans and e621 (Dec. 2014)
forum #137551 - Direct Description copy & paste on Posts (Sep. 2014)

forum #30719 - e621 Upload Policy,Artists & a suggestion (Mar. 2012)

-

Vore

forum #189603 - Vore & Venus Fly Traps or Pitcher Plants (Apr. 2016)

-

Voting

forum #172198 - Votes for images. Silly, depressing, useless. (Sep. 2015)

-

Wiki

forum #191799 - Wiki Discussion: Specific articles: Edits, questions, concerns, etc. (Apr. 2016)
forum #187125 Wiki guidelines? (locked) (Mar. 2016)
forum #159148- Wiki Standards: Editing and Content (May 2015)

   

forum links [depreciated]

▼ Click to collapse

Mine

Conjunctive tagging

forum #184444 - [gender1] [style1] * [gender2] [style2]
forum #184919 - [style1] [species1]_[genitalia1] * [style2] [species2]_[genitalia2]

https://e926.net/wiki/show?title=pseudo-penis

--
forum #189471 - Advanced tag discussion: Mutually-exclusive Body Types/Styles (anthro, feral, human, humanoid, taur, 'semi-anthro' etc.) (Apr. 2016)

forum #187706 - Advanced Policy Discussions: Implicative/Conjunctive/Redundant/Mutually-exclusive tag usage (Mar. 2016)

forum #185266 - Ambiguous tags Discussion/listing (Feb. 2016)

forum #187716 - Mammary tags discussion:[..] (Mar. 2016)

forum #140749 - Physical Gender Tag aliases/discussion (Oct. 2014)

forum #193528 - Unofficial PSA: invalid_tag vs. *_(disambiguation) (May 2015)

forum #159148 - Wiki Standards: Editing and Content (May 2015)

Others'

Conjunctive tagging

  • forum #182665 - Tag suggestion 2 of 2 (maybe 3): The big suggestion - Implied Species+gender tags [feb 2016] [The Masked Newfag]

: gendered species tags

- Add to conjunctive tag list

- related to paired gender/species tagging
- add to paired species/gender post: forum #184444

   

Archived forum tagging projects (by me)

[wip]

▼ Click to collapse

Thrown in here to for ease of reference/tracking. Newest first

  • 23. We have a penis_everywhere tag, do we have one for scenes where there are multiple penises present, but not 'everywhere'?
   

Misc. Quotes

[wip]

▼ quotes/comments

15 Tags with low count usage
- https://e926.net/forum/show/170417

14. integrity of site policies in relation to socio-moral/ethical influence upon said policies ('external'/internal) from an indirect and direct community pov

13. https://e926.net/comment/show/2579110 - artist prefs

12. https://e926.net/comment/show/76113 - 'childhood ruined'

1. Is e621 a porn site?

Kaeetayel said:
Like I said, ambig is a last resort. e6 is a porn site, after all, and very few people go around searching for ambiguous gendered characters.

Ratte said:
No it isn't. If e6 were a porn site there would be no point in safe-rated image hosting.

-

2. Tags, ??

Niceee said:
what I don't understand is why the fuss over it
it's just a label on something you enjoy (if you do) so I mean, what's the big deal?

imagoober said:
Blacklists or watchlists are much more difficult if the thing you're (un)interested in isn't tagged when appropriate.

--

3. Gender tagging - secondary sex characteristics and primary sex characteristics

▼ Click to collapse

Very related: forum #182543 (forum #182407)

I've been wondering if there's merit in creating a single tag for grouped humanoid secondary sex characteristics ('feminine'/'masculine' traits) that's separate from physical sex tags

▼ e.g:

'cuntboy', maleherm, female charr, some males all have a similar physical body traits, but not all of them are male

'dickgirl', herm, some females, girly males all have similar physical body traits, but not all of them are female

▼ i.e:
  • 1. have a single tag for a group of body traits commonly identified as 'feminine'
  • 2. have a single tag for a group of body traits commonly identified as 'masculine'
    • 2b. but separate from male

These tags already technically do exist, but not as single, unified tag

Also related is girly and tomboy

  

But, and this is a very big 'butt', as others mentioned both in here and the forum I linked, what counts as masculine and feminine are based on cultural norms, not really anything biological, or consistent

▼ one example is female charr:

you can label their body type as 'masculine', but that doesn't really mean anything outside of an established cultural context (not to mention it's rather sexist when you look at female body builders- muscular is not objectively synonymous with masculine)

-

It's a very ambiguous subject that's currently also a very touchy one [citation needed], so until some kind of consistent understanding is reached on the site about what exactly counts as 'feminine' or 'masculine', and that's translated to actual site rules/guidelines, then that ambiguity/inconsistency isn't likely going to go away

3a. Gender tagging: foo

4. Invalidations

5. Animal Rights

6. Tag disambiguation/qualifier standardization

7. Suggestions

  • https://e926.net/forum/show/197911
    • >Before making a new feature that takes years, I think admins just need to simply write information about "how to make multiple suggestions" in the suggestion page to avoid someone creates separate thread for each suggestion every now and then.

8. Common tag alias shortcuts [see also system aliases;proposed 'gender' tags]

9. Art/Artists

  • https://e926.net/forum/show/198347
    • >Whether you want people (aside from yourself) to enjoy your art is a question that each individual artist must answer. For most artists, it's rewarding and motivating when people enjoy their work. But for many artists, people enjoying their work is definitely not *the point*. It may be to understand X better, practice a technique, achieve a better result than last time, simply communicate your thoughts on a subject, or for a professional, simply get the job done well enough and move on.
    • People also typically have standards for -how- their work should be enjoyed. Acknowledging the artist as a person and writing a comment expressing your appreciation of the specific merits of their work, is immeasurably better than simply getting lost in the wank inside your own head. The latter tells them very little about the quality of the artwork, and a lot about you.

10. Implicative tagging

https://e926.net/forum/show/72397

11. https://e926.net/forum/show/148373

   

Forum Drafts

▼ drafts

e621 Colo(u)r Standardization

[v0.34 +/- 0.25]

▼ Colour standardization

Ok, here's an idea:

What if we had a fixed number of standard site colors, and used them accordingly for tags with high color counts?

eg fur, hair, eyes, theme, background etc.

According to this page, there are some basic colors found in English speaking communities:

▼ 'Common' set
  • black
  • gray/grey
  • white
  • blue (blue/indigo)
  • brown
  • green
  • orange
  • pink (violet)
  • purple (indigo/violet)
  • red
  • yellow

Personally, I'd prefer the rainbow colors from Physics:

▼ Rainbow set

black
gray/grey
white

red
orange
yellow
green
blue
indigo
violet

Since this a bit more international and fits well with the rainbow_* color tags too
-

But most english speaking communities [citation needed] seem to be familiar with the first group

There's also the issue of everything below blue:
people tend to blend blue, indigo, and violet together mentally. Which results in purples, pinks etc.

There's also no cyan; which falls between green and blue
---

Another option is to have all of those, but merge them together in the following way

  • Broad color
    • Specific color

E.g.

▼ Click to collapse
  • violet
    • pink
    • purple

or

  • pink
    • violet
  • purple
    • violet

-
Considerations:

Should we include cyan?

Multiple similar colors on a single post?

  • purple, violet, pink, etc

Multiple categories?

  • blue
    • cyan
  • green
    • cyan

Replies:
https://e926.net/forum/show/204414

[Back: titanmelon:index]