Tag Implication: mature_dickgirl -> mature_intersex

In category: Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

Implicating mature_dickgirlmature_intersex
Link to implication

Reason:

For consistency and blacklisting purposes.

Also: mature_hermmature_intersex


+1 to also implicate dickgirl and herm respectively.


animperfectpatsy said:
+1 to also implicate dickgirl and herm respectively.

Why are those even tags? Shouldn't it just be mature, dickgirl?


Dutchnoob said:
Why are those even tags? Shouldn't it just be mature, dickgirl?

They are used for "milf"-like characters, specifically.


Ratte said:
They are used for "milf"-like characters, specifically.

I mean, the point still stands. Wouldn't a milf be mature anyways; {also Dgirls couldn't really be milfs given a lack of a certain piece of anatomy but we'll skip that can} so wouldn't it still be mature, dickgirl. And "Milf" itself is subjective.


RenaDyne said:
I mean, the point still stands. Wouldn't a milf be mature anyways; {also Dgirls couldn't really be milfs given a lack of a certain piece of anatomy but we'll skip that can} so wouldn't it still be mature, dickgirl. And "Milf" itself is subjective.

Just read what mature's wiki says...

I say it be aliased to invalid_tag because of how many people think it's valid to tag posts with, when it's not.


Siral_Exan said:
Just read what mature's wiki says...

I say it be aliased to invalid_tag because of how many people think it's valid to tag posts with, when it's not.

I would imagine "Mature" would only really apply to people after the age of 40, where "Cougars" start being a thing.


RenaDyne said:
I would imagine "Mature" would only really apply to people after the age of 40, where "Cougars" start being a thing.

Did you read the tag wiki? "Mature" means 3 things on this site, and all three are already represented. "Cougar" is not a valid description for your implication either, it is an animal and not a female prowling for a male. That is mature_female.


Now, to the OP:
I suggest that we also finish the other intersexes as well, and have mature_maleherm imply mature_herm in tangent with the other implications from maleherm to herm.

So:
Implicating mature_dickgirlmature_intersex
Implicating mature_dickgirldickgirl
Implicating mature_hermmature_intersex
Implicating mature_hermherm
Implicating mature_cuntboymature_intersex
Implicating mature_cuntboycuntboy
Implicating mature_malehermmature_intersex
Implicating mature_malehermmaleherm
Implicating mature_malehermmature_herm

Just because they're not tagged doesn't mean they won't be tagged in the future. Nobody's uploaded (or tagged) art of it yet.


RenaDyne said:
I mean, the point still stands. Wouldn't a milf be mature anyways; {also Dgirls couldn't really be milfs given a lack of a certain piece of anatomy but we'll skip that can} so wouldn't it still be mature, dickgirl. And "Milf" itself is subjective.

Hence "-like" which you apparently didn't see.

Mature is too vague and people would use it (and have done so before) to tag mature content instead of characters of a certain agegroup. This is a tag that should be disambiguated.

Plus this cuts down an otherwise occupied tag search space. Things are done how they are for reasons.


Dutchnoob said:
Why are those even tags? Shouldn't it just be mature, dickgirl?

RenaDyne said:
I mean, the point still stands. Wouldn't a milf be mature anyways; {also Dgirls couldn't really be milfs given a lack of a certain piece of anatomy but we'll skip that can} so wouldn't it still be mature, dickgirl. And "Milf" itself is subjective.

Sure. However, consider a user searching milf who doesn't know the ins and outs of tag aliases, implications, and lookup. (Further, consider all the newbies calling any porn "hentai".) They don't know any better. With milf's current alias to mature_female, they will actually find roughly what they're looking for.

On the other hand, consider these users' browsing experience if milf were aliased to either of mature or female. If aliased to mature instead, milf would return any gender of mature character, so a search for milfs would also return posts containing (only) mature males, for instance. If aliased to female instead, a search for milfs would return slim young female characters among other "non-mature" body shapes.

If milf were simply invalidated, users lacking general tag awareness would not be able to find mature females through direct means (read: not user-friendly). Knowledgeable users could search mature female and find what they're looking for, but as always is the case, posts with multiple characters gunk up such search results. For example, that search would also return a post tagged for a mature male with a young, slim female.

Thus, compound tags like these do serve a purpose. Until we're able to group tags together per post, this is about the best we can do. Would you rather search big_dom_small_sub or wade through size_difference sex?


RenaDyne said:
I mean, the point still stands.

The point is lying on the floor :V


RenaDyne said:
I mean, the point still stands.

TheHuskyK9 said:
The point is lying on the floor :V

How does one define the orientation of something zero-dimensional?